Future Cities Africa

View Original

Giving Municipal Administrations Real Power to Run Their Cities

Your browser doesn’t support HTML5 audio

Giving Municipal Administrations Real Power to Run Their Cities

Who really runs South Africa's municipalities, and what would it take to change that? Ivor Chipkin unpacks the structural problems behind the crisis in local government and what it would actually take to fix them.


Download This Episode's MP3 File
The file will open in a new window. Click down arrow to download the file.

Where to subscribe: Apple Podcast | Google Podcasts | Spotify | Youtube | RSS


Innovation in Local Government series - presented by Business Engineering.

Guest: Ivor Chipkin, Researcher and Governance Specialist | Co-Founder and Director of the New South Institute

Host: Dan Claassen, MD, Future Cities Africa

South Africa's municipal crisis is not simply a matter of bad leadership or corrupt officials - it is structural. Ivor Chipkin, one of South Africa's foremost thinkers on the state, argues that municipal administrations as independent professional entities with their own powers have never properly been constituted in law. Until that changes, no amount of leadership reform will produce lasting results.

  • The institutional problem: The Municipal Systems Act left administrative authority largely in the hands of elected councils. City managers and municipal managers have no original powers of their own - they cannot appoint their own staff or make autonomous operational decisions. Everything depends on whether the political party in power chooses to respect their autonomy. In some Johannesburg administrations a functioning city management has existed; in others it has effectively not.
  • Johannesburg as a case study: Johannesburg's utilities - City Power and Joburg Water - were designed with genuine professional autonomy and ring-fenced finances. That model has been progressively hollowed out. Ring-fenced revenue was pooled into central municipal accounts and not returned. Billing responsibilities between the city and the utilities were never formally resolved and were handed to an IT system that no one fully understands. Board terms were shortened to one year, introducing annual instability that cascades through the organisations.
  • The Medellin comparison: EPM, Medellin's utility company, succeeded because it was given professional autonomy, protected cash flows, stable governance and measurable targets. It succeeded so well that it now sells utility services to other cities as a profit-making enterprise. The original design of Johannesburg's utilities pointed in the same direction - but the conditions that made EPM work were never sustained.
  • A reform already underway: The 2026 amendment to the Public Service Act, signed into law in April, for the first time transfers real administrative powers from cabinet ministers and MECs to director generals and heads of department. Ivor argues that something equivalent must now happen at municipal level - constituting the municipal administration as a sphere with its own powers, and ensuring that senior appointments are made on professional grounds rather than political ones.
  • The ask of new councils: Ivor's recommendation to incoming coalition governments after the 2026 elections is straightforward: agree, as part of coalition negotiations, to respect the autonomy of the municipal administration; appoint qualified and experienced professionals to key roles; and resist the temptation to govern operationally through political structures. It may not sound magical - but he argues the results would be.

Download This Episode's MP3 File
The file will open in a new window. Click down arrow to download the file.

Where to subscribe: Apple Podcast | Google Podcasts | Spotify | Youtube | RSS


Discover more from Future Cities Africa

See this content in the original post